International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)
Location: Mediterranean
Year: 2022
Project: Fisheries incentives and compensation schemes
Photo:Photo by Dima Pima on Unsplash
MFE was commissioned by IUCN to explore financial incentives applied to fisheries and environmental protection and their associated impacts to inform marine sustainability efforts in the Mediterranean.
Wild-capture fisheries make a significant contribution to global food security and nutrition. As the demand for seafood continues to rise, wild-capture fisheries in many regions still threaten the long-term sustainability of marine fish stocks and the resilience of some marine ecosystems. This is especially the case in the Mediterranean, which has a long history of fisheries overexploitation and habitat damage. The viability of Mediterranean fisheries is therefore increasingly under threat and their future relies on innovative and transformative change.
Given the growing interest and application of financial incentives as solutions to help drive the conservation of marine fish stocks and ecosystems, MFE investigated the use of financial incentives to support sustainable fisheries and environmental protection in the Mediterranean. The report was developed following a literature review of financial incentives applied to fisheries, supported by key informant interviews with experts in conservation finance, resource economics, and fisheries and marine conservation. The literature review and key informant interviews provided the current “state of affairs” in financial incentives applied to the fishing sector and helped synthesize best practices for future efforts, particularly for the Mediterranean. An interactive workshop allowed cross fertilization of ideas and discussion of the key findings from the literature review and KI interviews.
To see more of our work and latest projects visit our projects page.
CHECK OUT OUR PARTNERS
World Economic Forum (WEF)
The United Nations (UN)
Global Fishing Watch (GFW)
The Nature Conservancy (TNC)
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)
International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)
Mars
World Resources Institute (WRI)
NOAA Fisheries
MOWI
Fair Trade USA
Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS)
Environmental Justice Foundation (EJF)
The World Bank
Continental Grain Company (CGC)
World Wild Fund for Nature (WWF)
China Dialogue
MARS Petcare
The Commonwealth Secretariat
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Marine Stewardship Council (MSC)
Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs (DEFRA)
EU IUU Fishing Coalition
University of Cambridge
Oceana
Peter Pan Seafood
Compassion in World Farming (CIWF)
Seafish
Creative Python
Crivello Law
Deep-Ocean Stewardship Initiative (DOSI)
Blue Marine Foundation (BMF)
Government of the Federated States of Micronesia (FSM)
Birdlife International
Renewable Resources Group (RRG)
Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES)
First Nations Fisheries Council of British Columbia (FNFC)
Heriot Watt University (HWU)
INFOPESCA
IMEDEA
Marine Conservation Society (MCS)
Fisheries Innovation & Sustainability (FiS)
Anglo Northern Irish Fish Producers Org. (ANIFPO)
Northern Ireland Fish Producers' Organisation (NIFPO)
Eastern Inshore Fisheries Cons. Authority (EIFCA)
National Oceanic Resource Management Authority (NORMA)
Pacific Island Forum Fisheries Agency (FFA)
Office for Environmental Protection (OEP)
World Wise Seafoods
On the Hook (OTH)
The Sustainable Eel Group
South Pacific Commission (SPC)
Oregon State University (OSU)
Pew Charitable Trusts (Pew)
Planet Tracker
Quiñenco
The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)
San Diego State University (SDSU)
Scripps Institution of Oceanography (SIO)
Seas at Risk
San Francisco State University (SFSU)
Stanford University
Steer
Stockholm University
Sustainable Fisheries Partnership (SFP)
Too Big To Ignore (TBTI)
UC Davis
UC San Diego (UCSD)
Universitat de les Illes Balears (UIB)
Ioteq
Ulster Wildlife
The University of British Columbia (UBC)
University of Washington (UW)
Waitt Institute (WI)
Wisconsin Energy Group (WEC)
WorldFish
UpLift
Seafood Advisory
Fishwise Limited
testimonials
"Global Fishing Watch hired the MarFishEco team to conduct a horizon scan focused on utilizing big data and AI to address the impacts of climate change. Through a comprehensive review of research trends, funding portfolios, and public media awareness, the MFE team provided a foundational understanding for GFW, which was further developed through key informant interviews and in-depth analyses. The outputs from MFE were excellent, addressing questions posed by multiple members of the GFW team and board, and were consistently clear and concise. The final report clearly presented potential paths forward for GFW (including the intersections between them), avoiding unnecessary detail and including many clear visual representations of the findings. Working with MFE was a great experience. We were kept informed, the project adhered to the planned timeline, and the team went above and beyond to address additional questions as GFW integrated the findings into our research pipeline and project portfolio. We look forward to collaborating with MFE again."
Sarah Bladen
Chief, Strategy & External Affairs, Global Fishing Watch
“The Coalition contracted MarFishEco to delve deeper into their Global Charter for Fisheries Transparency, ten policy principles seeking to bring about change in fisheries governance and transparency. The MFE team researched peer-reviewed and policy literature along with public media content to produce an explanatory report backed by real-world case studies to complement the Charter’s ten principles. The MFE team worked closely with the Coalition team in DC to ensure the report was constructed in a way that balanced potential political sensitivities with realistic and impactful examples of fisheries mismanagement and human rights and labor abuses. MFE also drafted a user guide to help those interested in advocating for fisheries transparency better navigate what can be an overwhelming space. We enjoyed working with MFE and appreciated their ability to refine many ideas driven by a large internal authorship group. It was also very clear that the MFE team was well-versed in both the expert content related to global fisheries and illegal fishing as well as the juggling of multiple versions and comment sets.”
Emily Porterfield & Maisie Pigeon
Associate & Director, Oceana
"MarFishEco worked with FAO and INFOPESCA on a fish landing site diversification project in 2018. During this assignment, Andrew showed his interest and knowledge in marine fisheries issues, including infrastructure needs, by addressing the needs of stakeholders and fishers. I was particularly impressed by their innovative actions regarding information and data collection, and the very logical way of presenting the information at the projects final multi-stakeholder workshop. I hope to work with MarFishEco again in the future when we develop the work further."
Helga Josupeit
Senior Fisheries Officer, FAO
"We contracted MarFishEco to undertake a study on the implementation of the Common Fisheries Policy external dimensions and best practices. The purpose of the study was to take stock of the effectiveness of EU implementation of the rules on ensuring legal, sustainable and equitable fisheries in its fishing activity outside EU waters and thus its contribution to the achievement of relevant SDGs. The report contributed to the wider Fish Forward II project. Working with Andrew was an easy and efficient experience. Clear timelines were set out at each stage of the project for a seamless delivery of a high-quality report. I happily recommend working with MarFishEco, a trustworthy and responsive fisheries consultancy that produces rigorous, impactful and communicable outputs."
Rhona Kent
Fisheries Policy Officer, WWF
"We contracted MarFishEco to produce an analysis of the current state of marine tourism activities in Mexico and to develop a fisheries analysis. Hiring them was a great decision, the team organized a meeting with our internal staff, developed a timeline and clear deliverables and then got to work quickly and efficiently. MFE produced excellent, comprehensive economic analyses and went above and beyond with this work. They have subsequently produced 2 peer-review papers which have benefited our outreach and funding streams immensely."
Mariana Walther Mendoza
Gulf of California Coordinator, The Nature Conservancy
"We had the pleasure to work with MarFishEco as part of the revision of the Capture Fisheries Standard (CFS). MFE did a deep dive into the Resource Management section of Fair Trade USA’s fisheries standard, focusing on identifying ways to improve the requirements around governance, overfishing, and data collection. Additionally, MFE evaluated how to expand the scope of applicability of the CFS to include freshwater fisheries, and additional considerations for enhanced fisheries. Their recommendations and final report were key to finalizing the Draft CFS for public consultation. Working with MFE was great. They were efficient, very thorough in their reviews, and went above and beyond what was asked to make sure the deliverables were exactly what we were looking for. I look forward to working with MFE again on future projects!"
Juliana Herrera
Seafood Standards Manager, Fair Trade USA
"Working with the MarFishEco team was a great experience. In collaboration with our in-house team, MFE was tasked with reviewing the current state of best practices in fisheries gear trials and helping to organize a stakeholder workshop to discuss the formation of best practice guidelines. Following the report MFE produced for us, we contracted them a gain to help develop an online tool that can be used to calculate the financial consequences of changing or modifying fishing gears. Both the report and the tool are of an excellent quality and exactly what we were looking for. I look forward to collaborating with the MFE team again in the near future."
Hazel Curtis
Chief Economist, Seafish Industry Authority
"China Dialogue Trust commissioned MarFishEco to write a report examining the editorial outputs of a two-year project on sustainable seafood. Andrew analysed a large collection of articles, web statistics and workshop events to provide an objective assessment of our reporting efforts and how these explain China’s role in the global ocean. There was clear planning and communication of objectives from the start. The team was fast and extremely communicative, enjoyable to work with and committed himself to delivering against a really tight schedule. They provided direction where necessary and were also totally open to any feedback or changes. Their knowledge of the fishing industry, policy and governance was a big asset and greatly added to the quality of the report."
Jessica Aldred
Special Projects Editor, China Dialogue
"Working with MarFishEco was an absolute pleasure. The team generated highly-technical comments on potential fisheries impacts from offshore wind development in California in an exceedingly short timeframe. Andrew was inquisitive, pro-active, and incredibly responsive to feedback and follow-up questions. Not only did MarFishEco deliver scientific expertise, they were a delight to work with, advancing the project cheerfully and professionally. I look forward to working with MarFishEco again."
Sandy Aylesworth
Director, Pacific Ocean Initiative, Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
"I retained Dr. Andrew Johnson and the MFE team to consult in a lawsuit involving an aquaculture stock die-off due to a power outage in Juneau, Wisconsin, USA in 2019. Based on MFE’s extensive experience in aquaculture and their review of published and peer reviewed literature, the MFE team provided data-driven estimates and projections related to expected mortality rates in similarly situated farms and identified the equipment and process weaknesses in the Plaintiff’s operations. MFE’s work led directly to the case resolving without the need for a trial. Andrew and the MFE team was resourceful, available and a pleasure to work with throughout our partnership on the case. Andrew and the MFE are uniquely qualified to act as expert consultants. I have no hesitation recommending MarFishEco to anyone with the need for a true expert in aquaculture."
Travis J. Rhoades
Partner, Crivello Law Firm
"The Commonwealth Connectivity Agenda for Trade and Investment contracted MarFishEco Fisheries Consultants Ltd to author a paper on the State of Digital Fisheries in the Commonwealth. We confirm that the team at MFE held itself to the highest standards providing us with value beyond what was expected. MarFishEco’s professionalism and excellence were evident throughout. They delivered a comprehensive report on fisheries digitalisation, thoroughly analysing the state of digital innovation across our regions. Their structured approach and insightful recommendations across digital innovations, data infrastructure, business development, and enabling environments were invaluable. MarFishEco’s expertise and dedication have provided us with critical insights to advance sustainable and equitable fisheries. It is for this reason that we confidently recommend MarFishEco Fisheries Consultants Ltd for assignments that lean towards Fisheries, Digital Fisheries, Market Research and Planning, among others."
Dr Benjamin Kwasi Addom
Adviser, Agriculture & Fisheries Trade Policy, Commonwealth Connectivity Agenda
"MarFishEco exceeded our expectations in delivering an "EU Fishmeal and Fish Oil Policy Factsheet" for CIWF. Their expertise in fisheries trade and management was evident in the comprehensive classification system they developed for FMFO routes into the EU market. The detailed statistical summary and descriptive list of relevant EU policies and trade agreements provided invaluable insights. Their work has helped enhance our advocacy efforts by highlighting key regulatory issues. MarFishEco’s professionalism and dedication make them an outstanding partner for any organization seeking expert fisheries consulting services."
Dr Elena Lara
Senior Research and Public Affairs Advisor, Compassion in World Farming
"The Sustainable Eel Group (SEG) hired the MarFishEco team in 2023 to field test and review the SEG Standard in North America A Code of Conduct for a Sustainable Eel Sector in North America – V1). The work involved a desk-based review component as well as a field test on the East Coast of the USA, examining eel fisheries and aquaculture operations. Working with the MFE team was an easy and pleasant experience. Before any contracts were signed, they ensured that all parties were aligned regarding the final deliverables and that all travel logistics were feasible within the timeline we requested. After signing, MFE kept us updated on progress, managed stakeholders in the field with ease, and provided exactly what we were asking for. I have no reservations about recommending MFE for work that involves evaluating theory on paper, testing it in practice, and reporting findings concisely with clear and practicable recommendations."
David Bunt
Director of Conservation Operations Sustainable Eel Group
newsletter